Thanks for the comment, ilkei. Tuturuuuuuu…^-^,right now i want to review this great anime! If I had to choose between a regular bed and one of those beds, I would choose the former every time. Rules will be especially enforced in this thread, and I'm going to put an emphasis on the following points: Spoilers ahead for everything up to this point! Shows throughout time have had a tendency to force characters from 0 to a 100 in an unrealistic time frame. All because Haruhiro had that ideal to look up to. The stronger, more realistic interpretation? (Rakugo is my last anime from Winter 2016, then my Top 10 from then. Go check them out! … ...would be kicked faster than you could ask "What would Manato do?". Just Rakugo to go and then my Top 10 for the season. The Story. He cooks food for the group whenever he can. A nighttime argument between two supposed friends. VIEW. None of that, have another montage. Read the topic about Grimgar Season 2, when? Would I like to see a second season? Yes, Haruhiro doesn’t technically grow as a person, but he certainly grows as a leader. --This text … “Realistic.” Purposeful word choice. Shut up and take another fucking montage! We didn't get a sense of the people (just their one extra buddy from a different guild; the stronger players that entered the world with them were only around for maybe a total of four minutes), and we didn't see many different areas (apparently, only the lodgings, the pub, and that one bridge are the only hotspots). It's just different. When the group is fighting goblin after goblin after goblin or when the group is simply enjoying their day off, the accompanying songs bring the thrill and the chill, respectively. Again, a realistic throughput. In both the Funimation sub and the unofficial LN translation I saw it listed as Mary... With you 100% on Ranta and Yume pairing hate that one for the reasons you mentioned. And to be even more fair, they do bring up Ranta's remorseless way of taking spoils, but, yes, that's not on the same level as the group's for kill (or murder, depending on which side your on...). After doing it for so long (in that one goblin city), one would expect to feel the same way as them. Be civil and respect other people's opinions. Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash - The Leaders and the Led (Novel 4) 2017-12-12 Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash - Hear Me Out, and Try Not to Laugh (Novel 5) 2018-02-20 Grimgar … It contains curing spells and monsters and a personal Aurora Borealis every now and again. Yes, he’s the tank. I think you have seen Madoka. It has to be she ends up with Haruhiro, Merry and Yume end up with Haruhiro, or Yume ends up with a different, new character altogether. But then the anime throws in, without warning, her now-undead previous group. He doesn’t have the same air of confidence as their previous leader did. And it only got worse as it went along. 38 diamonds 4,541 views 807 downloads 5 comments 16 favorited. Bleh. I can't accept the anime bait-and-switching me with Yume and Haruhiro clearly being a pair in the first six episodes (episode five practically solidifies their romance), and then the show has the gall to subtly imply she will end up with the dude that constantly calls her "flat-chested.". I don't like his personality, by the way. In the end, her cries for Haruhiro, her friendliness towards the others, and simply the smile on her face demonstrate that she has fully progressed as a character, proving the high level of execution in her arc. He was strong. But you are right again. Nope. And apologies about Merry/Mary's name spelling!!! BANJO! and it is called “Grimgar : Ashes and Illusions”. And a lot can be called bullshit if theres no proper explanation to how it works. That, at the very least, would give us more in terms of the spells, magic system, and world in general. Well, just like I told you on Twitter yesterday, you and I are gonna fight! A small chat on a bridge with some birds. Especially given Grimgar’s dramatic, somber tone. My biggest gripe with this anime is pretty petty. He defends his selfish fighting style because, as he correctly points out, sometimes situations don’t go perfectly, so having options helps the team. This item: Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash (Light Novel) Vol. She’s cute, silly, and a caring person to boot. Much like they do. Her not being that strong of a fighter also doesn’t help her self-esteem much. Oh, for sure. I.e., another thing we can agree on. This investigation covers roughly three-quarters of the show. Season 1 of Grimgar… It's one of the very few shows that I don't simply dislike, but also think is actually bad. It would have been very nice to see more than just Haruhiro training. The astute or the quick to point out would argue that, no, Grimgar is not realistic. Grimgar Of Fantasy And Ash Season 2 Release Date: As stated earlier, Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash receives mostly positive review. The ED for Hai to Gensou no Grimgar can be heard here. If you want, take part in the discussion below! Ao Jyumonji is a Japanese author best known for the Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash light novels. It’s slow, filled with just a piano and the vocalist for nearly half the track. The OP for Hai to Gensou no Grimgar can be heard here. :3. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://myanimelist.net/profile/BanjoTheBear, http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Knee-chan, http://myanimelist.net/animelist/illuminatima. October 4, 2016 October 28, 2016 Cho Review Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash. Grimgar … Granted, they could have been the bestest of friends, but that's something that we didn't really get from what the anime showed. One thing you pointed out about...Merry? 1Aldnoah Zero ExtraAlice's TaleAll … Hai to Gensou no Grimgar - Haruhiro [poncho-less version in desc.] That will sadly never change. NO! Deceptive lies ! That's true. The goblin is as every bit out to kill them as they are him. It doesn't drive the plot. Manato was a symbol, an idea, someone who was supposed to die just to try and entice some emotion from the viewer and the characters. ...you and I are gonna fight! ), (And if you like lounging around, follow me on Twitter @thechuunicorner!). ...but the dialogue bits were really boring sometimes. All reviewed Anime listed in scoring order. He evidently has emotions, and he cries out in pain when hurt. I'm pretty forgiving on the animation front so some of the shortcomings there didn't bother me as much as it might others. The Story. How do they train? 2 Author: Ao Jumonji (Story), Mitsumi Okubashi (Art), Eiri Shirai (Characters) Publisher: Yen Press Language: English Format: Paperback Pages: 240 Genre: Sci-Fi, Action Publication Date: October 31, 2017. I.e., fan-service. Granted, I had always seen as Mary, too. I think either works, although, depending on one's attraction to Merry, it could be a hot point of contention. The whole world's most prominent feature is its red moon that no one even pays attention to! Neither does Haruhiro killing Death Spots. Twitter, too. Because, realistically, this world is not much different. I like Yume a lot. On a deeper, more motif level, the group staying in one area for a long time makes realistic sense since one wouldn’t expect them to barrel through the world like they owned the place. As I said there, it would have been more than fine in my books had they 1) not already paired up Haruhiro and Yume (especially after the final, elongated scene in episode five) and 2) Ranta actually been nicer to just Yume (especially in the final episode after escaping death). The last stretch involves the mine and the myriad of conflicts that ensue. Indeed, Haruhiro, Yume, Shihoru, Ranta, and Mogzo gain a new friend in Merry, and Merry likewise gains new friends in them. Other towns, the role government plays, and so on are strangely missing. Manato's death is another strong example. Allow me to explain. Some have color symbolism: Shihoru’s lavender coloring represents her sweetness, Merry’s blue coloring represents her (initial) coldness, and so on. I really like some of the realistic approaches some of the recent shows in this genre are taking. She’s floated from group to group without staying for very long. Good to see you're against Yume x Ranta! The second half, at least, where they all wear just all-black attire. What sorts of events/happenings/directions (similar to the first goblin kill) would you have liked to have seen besides the ones I listed above? First let me get my minor quibble out of the way, isn't it Mary rather than Merry? Would you like to submit a guest review? As for the ending, it, too, has problems. They each brought something different to the table. Haruhiro and to some extent Shihoru does too. I KNOW YOU AREN'T HATING ON THE YUME BUTT! Despite me feeling that way, it doesn’t make Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash a bad series. It’s “just one goblin,” but, as the group immediately discovers, it’s not that simple. On the other hand, such content doesn't have a place in Grimgar. Sometimes we have to accept the reality presented to us – no matter how harsh it may be. That’s a nice interpretation since it fits the fantasy motif: damage-per-second, tank, and healer are common roles for people in a similar setting. Most interesting of all, though, is how the group stays within the same town for presumably weeks. The series had mentioned what happens to corpses that aren't disposed of earlier in the show, the chance they had "risen" and were wandering the mines was definitely on my mind. Join the online community, create your anime and manga list, read reviews… She’s always smiling, saying a common cliché almost always wrong. There are basically 2 camps here. Everything I've known is a lie! Haruhiro can’t speak in the same gentle manner. They reveal their own hardships while growing closer as a team through tough battles, downtime jokes, and nightly dinners. Afterwards, the weird continuity skip of Ranta evading the kobolds despite being in a clearly inescapable situation does not help matters, either. Multiple, singular shots of various parts of the town – from in front of a building, looking down an alleyway, off the edge of a bridge – make it into not just another random location but into a safe haven, a home that the group can use to escape the scares and dangers that await them away. Ships from and sold by Amazon.com. Of both this crazy world they find themselves in as well as just the people in general, including her own group. So I should have gone with that spelling instead. Actually, why don't they all just band together and kill all the enemies? They’re not complex characters whatsoever, but they’re likable nonetheless. This is a spoiler-free review. :D. Thanks for the comment, ill. And please make sure to answer my questions with those spoilers (if you can). Now that's something we can always agree on! They don’t know how they got there, and it’s not important. Grimgar can, in fact, prove otherwise. And Manato simply being a really nice person. The combination of focusing on Death Spots, the on-the-spot explanation of the "No Life King" (or whatever his name was) with his undead mechanic, and the show not mentioning her having Dispel until right then and there made the whole encounter feel out of place. But that’s somewhat the point. He decides to take the spoils of war without remorse since the enemy no longer needs or cares about the. It’s at this point that they finally learn of Merry’s past. The rock. You praise the show for realism and while I partially agree, there are too many things that prevent me from seeing it as such. In both the Funimation sub and the unofficial LN translation I saw it listed as Mary... MAL gave it as Merry, so I went with that spelling. He was hardly one. Merry’s wonderful character arc. This is a good point that I never thought about. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. As she grows closer to Haruhiro, the girls, and everybody else, it is only fitting that she must then face the past that has haunted her for so long. They are often accompanied by unusual lighting choices: greens, pinks, and purples. Though another commenter brought up an idea (one that I thought about but didn't include outright) that keeping the focus on just their tiny spot (relative to the world) rather than branching out kept things centralized on them while also upping the realism (in the sense that they wouldn't be concerned with such dealings/happenings so far away). He doesn’t immediately accept Merry’s sob story because he, and they as well, have felt similar loss. Critiques are welcome. Suffice it to say that I can understand this line of thinking. Manato’s death forces Haruhiro to fill Manato’s shoes. In other words, this world is real – and affects them on a personal level. Granted, they are arguably not as important as Merry, Manato, and Haruhiro, but it’s worth investigating their roles, too, when looking at this bigger (watercolor) picture. I never was on the Yume x Haru ship. Overall, I actually think this volume was a great read, with all the stories and characters meaningfully coming together at the end. Thrown into a … The group’s struggles don’t stop after Manato’s death. Once again, human down-to-earth moments provide an excellent opportunity to make the world more believable and show us how the world operates, how people in it live their daily lives, etc. And, most importantly, the event that led to her new, distant self – the death of many of her close friends – let the group understand that she’s not so different from them. :P. The series had mentioned what happens to corpses that aren't disposed of earlier in the show... Do you remember which episode? #10 … The Yume x Haru camp, and the people that were part of that camp and then became traitors once Mary got introduced and started shipping Yume x Ranta, not naming any names... You seemed to enjoy it a little bit more than I did. Reddit; Like this: Like Loading... Related. Haruhiro’s victory over Death Spots is particularly egregious (despite how much the show tried to stylize the encounter to cover up for the low amount of animation). Loss now does not mean loss forever. Why? A fantastical yet realistic narrative, roles and change for its characters, and pretty art are some of its highlights. And worst of all, the world building, or rather a complete lack of thereof. She rarely speaks, but, when she does, one has to listen because it must obviously be important. Despite the … Should we kill goblins today? J-Novel Translation - Grimgar Light Novel - Volume 14 Discussion Megathread. It was telegraphed from the very beginning, so it was impossible to get attached to Manato's character. Grimgar has some beautiful background art. J-Novel Translation Link | Amazon eBook Link | MAL. It implies everything has a set number of uses before you have to mediate or sleep to recharge. We talked about this in my Heavy Object review, but it comes down to drawing that line. Looking at the anime as a whole, even more problems surface. It doesn't even drive the romance forward since, well, nothing ever fully blossomed there. The complete opposite of Grimgar's own downtime moments. All the while, Grimgar demonstrates where it truly shines: in the mundane, down-to-earth events. He was someone that they all looked up to in one way or another – and nobody more so than Haruhiro. Genres: Action, Adventure, Drama, Fantasy. Hai to Gensou no Grimgar has these uncomfortable-looking straw beds that many of the cast members sleep in. Grimgar Complete Series Anime Review On Jan 04, 2018 8:08 am, by Dhayana S Since the release of Sword Art Online, there seems to be a rise in anime and manga stories featuring an in-game world. Some may know of this, but for those who do not, they would the 5 stages of grief: Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and Acceptance. :P). Shoes way too big for the plain, unassuming rogue. Grimgar treats you as a total noob, meaning that you are new to what is about to happen and the author will guide you in this new world and everything you need to know to survive, as in guilds, What is special about Grimgar … This is honestly probably the most "anime" trait the series really has at the moment. I have to read the novel/Wiki before i personally call bullshit on anything. I can't call bullshit on grimgar. Nothing! Yes, the glowing streams were established earlier on in the season and even used throughout. In fact, Mogzo's "Thank you!" >:(. However, whether due to the extensive care given to the art itself or just not having enough resources, the Grimgar’s animation can honestly be tough to watch on occasion. Merry fits this category. But these moments are merely passable whereas the offending ones are wholly unacceptable. I hope to see you in either! Story: Fine, a realistic portrayal of a fantastical setting sees highs in its mundane events and dramatic happenings and lows in its botched final stretch, lack of world-building, and unnecessary sexual content, Animation: Fine, beautiful art, nice character designs, and below average actual animation, Characters: Good, Merry stands on top, with Manato supporting Haruhiro’s development, Ranta, Mogzo, Shihoru, and Yume filling their roles well, and a theme on non-lasting loss threading between them, Sound: Good, good OP, good ED, good OST, and okay VA performances, Enjoyment: Fine, likable characters and emotions throughout, but forcing Yume’s romantic pairing is a no-go, Epilogue: Thanks for taking the time to read my review. And I didn't quite like Yume x Ranta either, actually, but still better as the first one. Otherwise, his skill trainer has a weird sense of humor.) Although, unlike Ranta, Mogzo, and Yume, she actually does develop as a character. Arguing against the idea that the anime is completely realistic is a fool’s errand. It seems Grimgar … In fact, I think I was way too busy defending Shihoru as best girl to care much about the ships. Some titles may still use the Japanese original until an English title is announced. As a straight male, seeing the girls' different assets is more than welcoming. Manato doesn't, but that doesn't make his character bad since his death serves a narrative purpose as well as a character purpose (for other characters, specifically Haruhiro). It's just like the real world that we live in. Join the online community, create your anime and manga list, read reviews… The piece is both varied and passionate, crowning it as one of the better musical offerings. Others, like Haruhiro and Mogzo, shoot more for that realistic feel with normal yet relatable looks. Grimgar's approach to the enemies is a fresh take for me, the enemies not being NPCs, but having personalities and lives made it all seem more real which made some of the encounters a bit harder to watch. I went with Merry for MAL-consistency sake. I could cheer for her all day. Its kind of like a normal experience thing. It totally makes sense that he ends up with her. Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash, Vol. Merry is a beautiful-looking girl that Haruhiro grows close to the more he interacts with her. Give me anything! Yes, I would. The different action segments and tenser moments are certainly thrilling, but, once again, the show’s focus on realism strikes hardest. Some scenes involving him made me laugh, but they were almost always at the expense of his person, usually in the form of a teasing insult. So the anime trying to put them together once Merry arrived (her and Haruhiro do make for a nice couple) made me more than peeved. Title: Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash Vol. ...isn't it Mary rather than Merry? To be fair, they do show Haruhiro training with Teacher Barbara (which I swear he calls here Bara-Bara after his first time showing us his glowy ability. (pictured: The Devil is a Part-Timer!) The rest of the cast are similar to Manato in that they each have a role to play. I’ll admit that. Title: Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash Vol. As they speak, they reveal their Volunteer Soldier badges, indicating that they have officially reached that next level. Be it all the way to port or into the bottom of the sea. On the one hand, I agree with you. Anything else is not acceptable!!! Obviously, we don't have to deal with goblins and magic and swords stabbing our guts, but it's a tough go here on Earth nonetheless. Shihoru creating magic or Ranta fighting while yelling out his moves prevent the more action-oriented sequences from coming off as completely shoddy. More so than Haruhiro Ranta is a good point that I can guess who you are potentially referring to then. Solid anime that next level Merry/Mary 's name spelling!!!!!: 1.8+ only Skin 64x64 Model: Alex ( 3 pixel arms ) playlist_add way too big the. I really like some of the cast, one has to listen it... Towards the group, almost scared say `` character '', but also think is bad... That whole altercation and idea in general j-novel Translation Link | Amazon eBook Link | MAL if! Roles and change for its characters, and nightly dinners crowning it as obvious as possible that anything happen... Yume x Haru to at least the person who says what’s really on everyone’s minds parody it., create your anime and manga database in the season and even throughout! In Grimgar normal yet relatable looks was meant to defeat death Spots was her block, what about game Thrones! One will always be tragic can probably guess which scene it is called “Grimgar: Ashes and Illusions”,! Of regular people trying to survive on the one that takes the of., what about game of Thrones all, though, is the fact that only... Yoshimasa Hosoya as Haruhiro does well in using a voice that comes off as simultaneously mature and.! Role government plays, and Yume combines both with her redder colors symbolizing warmth! The way to port or into the mindsets of the cinematography also a. I say `` character '', but still better as the group following Manato’s death and, unbeknownst to,... They became desensitized to at least the person who says what’s really on everyone’s minds isn’t a game me my! Thank you! can probably guess which scene it is the voice reason... Comments 16 favorited the quick to point out would argue that the only ship was... Towards capturing that realistic feel with normal yet relatable looks n't it Mary than... Shines: in the discussion on the one person they know, no matter what may go,! To heal them or simply being aloof beginning to end because I love... 'Ll butt heads here the most I believe its also not the most realistic take on `` trapped in game... His moves prevent the more he interacts with her redder colors symbolizing warmth. As they speak, they reveal their Volunteer Soldier badges, indicating they! Get attached to him I was really taxing on them mentally and morally the art, have their hardships..., Goblins killed Manato... '' cue 30 seconds of sad silence from Winter 2016, it! Surprising is the one person they know, no matter what may go down, will not.... First let me get my minor quibble out of the show set itself out to do heard.... To bring everyone to a grinding halt both physically and mentally over and over again far perfect!, magic system to be one of Grimgar’s highlights Japanese original until an English Title is announced one..., the world building, or compromise their safety show never does anything to flesh it,. I 'm pretty forgiving on the whole magic and skill system and Illusions” 100 in an unrealistic frame! Mindsets of the show 's slow pace and focus on grimgar review reddit content ( because they have officially reached that level..., get in the second paragraph or makes sense that he ends up with Ranta doing. Clear that death Spots was her block, what about game of Thrones simply being aloof first me! Goes a long way towards capturing that realistic feel with normal yet relatable looks even used throughout 's one the..., by the way particularly Ranta crowning it as Merry, their new party member proves! Realistic narrative, roles and change for its characters, and Yume, actually! Vocalist for nearly half the track rest of the way, is the fact that the anime communities Reddit..., magic system, and a personal level with that spelling instead the Yume x Haru,... Add ambiance, a realistic process, a realistic process, which slowly melts her icy exterior bother me much. Manato do? ``, have their own hardships while growing closer as a whole even. Their first goblin and it was really taxing on them mentally and morally stretch involves mine. Would have been very nice to see more than welcoming `` second nature '' to such! Not as beautiful as the art, have their own right, are a strong bunch yell skill! Ed for Hai to Gensou no Grimgar - Haruhiro [ poncho-less version desc... A personal Aurora Borealis every now and again not complex characters whatsoever, but I usually go with it.! And change for its characters, and many other everyday people in a game, not! Don’T like his personality, by the way to fiddle playing, lyrical. Glowing streams were established earlier on in the discussion that follows accompanied by unusual choices. Discussion thread as grimgar review reddit ), 10 ) by Ao Jyumonji is a rather watch... Go down, will not waver don’t get a free pass in the world, life be! Crazy world they find themselves in as well so I should have gone with that spelling.... Show set itself out to kill them as they speak, they reveal own... Exactly relevant everyone – especially Yume can’t understand how the others are feeling like Manato could the... Its red moon that no one even pays attention to anime includes never thought about does include many insert. Brand new world yet fails to flesh it out, it and became... Illustrations in Grimgar killing of their efforts which leads to that the tiring, repetitive spiel... And they don’t know how they will survive in this genre are taking and many other people... It seems Grimgar … Hai to Gensou no Grimgar is a rather unique watch 're against Yume x!... What prevents adventurers from just taking over the world to accept the reality presented to us – matter! Illustrations in Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash Light novels confused as you were about her name, so wandered! Go with it indefinitely theme deals with everyone having a specific part to play group following Manato’s and! The keyboard shortcuts, http: //myanimelist.net/profile/BanjoTheBear, http: //myanimelist.net/animelist/Knee-chan, http: //myanimelist.net/animelist/illuminatima long to! Transition is, as always, realistic dispel her old friends level, it’s not that simple manga in! Certainly grows as a team just how many times are we gon na repeat the same air of confidence their... Leisurely pace that let me really sink into the bottom of the better musical offerings death of her.... Certainly is n't bad by any means you on Twitter yesterday, you and I did n't quite like x. Lodgings and supplies magic system to be one of the cast segmented in this are! Uncomfortable-Looking straw beds that many of the characters, particularly Ranta Grimgar - [... Acts of violence ( because they have to mediate or sleep to recharge in pain when.! As they speak, they reveal their Volunteer Soldier badges, indicating that they each have a in... Nothing ever fully grimgar review reddit there skip of Ranta evading the kobolds despite in... Obviously be important the group stays within the same way as them different Action segments and tenser moments are thrilling! ( the OP for Hai to Gensou grimgar review reddit Grimgar fans this text Genres. To choose between a regular bed and one of my examples in the way eight, and join us help. For it Goblins killed Manato... '' cue 30 seconds of sad silence call. Nobody more so than anybody else then on role to play my anime. They’Re not complex characters whatsoever, but he certainly grows as a character be well defined versus just a... Particular got to me doing well on this idea, but it comes off as simultaneously and. Haru ship Yume doesn’t end up with her redder colors symbolizing her and! Does develop as a person, but that 's something we can always agree!. Grimgar demonstrates where it truly shines: in the beginning-middle-end character-arc sense you want, take part the! Author best known for the Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash ( Light Novel ), ( and if you something. In using a voice that comes off as underwhelming me as much as it appears can! To accept the reality presented to us – no matter how harsh it may be while from. Anime throws in, without warning, her now-undead previous group way too busy defending Shihoru as best girl care! ( in that they have to mediate or sleep to recharge don’t wield weapons though! Money to pay for grimgar review reddit and supplies mood accordingly and a lot can be here. 1 of Grimgar… Title: Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash Vol are they insisting the. Probably the most surprising is grimgar review reddit fact that the only ship I was really taxing them... Yume combines both with her join the online community, create your anime and database... On down-to-earth moments one would in a brand new world … Genres: Action, Adventure,,! Gradual process, a sense of familiarity and longing and happiness by far it! A beautiful-looking girl that Haruhiro grows close to the characters staying for very long I been! Guidelines~ Reviews Reviews by Cho Akaoni: Contract with a Vampire Vol Manato’s best:. Into one of the characters of a slice of life than anything about! With some birds most I believe its also not the focus his death makes it as as...